Picture supply: Getty Photographs
Greggs (LSE:GRG) shares have suffered a dramatic 49% fall from grace over the past 14 months. Because the begin of 2022, the drop is 51%.
And regardless of the odd little burst right here and there in 2025, this FTSE 250 inventory is exhibiting no indicators of absolutely recovering any time quickly. Actually, it’s now languishing on the identical stage it was all the best way again in early 2019!
However absolutely it’s only a matter of time earlier than the beloved baker’s shares begin recovering? To get an concept of when that may occur, I turned to AI assistant ChatGPT to see what it ‘thinks’. Right here’s the way it answered.
Bruised however not damaged
First off, the bot mentioned what I think is the case right here: Greggs is “bruised” however the “fundamentals aren’t damaged“. Within the 13 weeks to 27 September, whole gross sales have been up 6.1%, and so they’ve risen 6.7% 12 months so far. That doesn’t appear to be a disaster.
Sadly although, buyers weren’t listening to these figures. As a substitute, they centered on like-for-like gross sales in company-managed retailers, which solely rose 1.5% in these 13 weeks (and a couple of.2% 12 months so far).
Like-for-like measures gross sales development at present retailers, stripping out the impact of recent openings and closures. Basically, it’s a greater indicator of underlying demand and buyer site visitors tendencies. And with the UK retail market on its knees proper now attributable to inflation and weak client confidence, that is problematic.
Again in the summertime, Greggs warned that this 12 months’s working revenue will seemingly are available in lighter than 2024, because it grapples with the additional tens of tens of millions in annual employment prices. Traders are nervous companies is perhaps within the firing line once more within the price range later this month.
When may issues recuperate?
This final level is one thing that ChatGPT fully fails to say. However I feel it’s vital, because the insurance policies introduced (or not) within the forthcoming price range might affect investor sentiment by some means.
In spite of everything, Greggs employs tens of hundreds of individuals, so small tax and wage modifications can actually add up. And if buyers lose much more religion within the course of the UK financial system, this might have a detrimental knock-on impact for Greggs’ development and its share value.
By way of firm operations, ChatGPT mentioned progress will seemingly be made “by means of a sequence of boring, better-than-feared” buying and selling updates.
Once I pushed it to offer me a timeline, it mentioned its base case was “early indicators of restoration inside six to 12 months“, if Greggs delivers two stable updates exhibiting improved like-for-like gross sales development.
Sycophancy
One large downside with ChatGPT is that it tends to be overly agreeable, In different phrases, it usually echoes customers’ views again to them, just like social media echo chambers.
Researchers have known as this ‘sycophancy’. For inventory analysis, I feel this tendency will be very harmful, for apparent causes.
Subsequently, I might by no means let it make an funding resolution for me.
My view
Greggs shares are at present buying and selling for simply 12.4 instances ahead earnings. Not solely is that this an enormous low cost to the 10-year common (22.5), however the dividend yield is now at 4.3%.
The near-term outlook is murky. However with the inventory at a steep low cost and providing an honest revenue yield, I reckon it’s a long-term shopping for alternative price excited about.
